Utah: Clothes, Panic & Flashbacks

by Jane Devin on July 1, 2010

She walks with a certain gait. She knows where she is going, and she smiles the whole way. Her skin is tanning booth brown, her teeth are bleach white, and her shoes cost more than the entire contents of my suitcase. Her boobs are squished together and hoisted up so that her cleavage starts just beneath her collarbones. Despite the heat of the day, Her hair stays in place – a fashionable highlighted bob that frames her perfectly made-up face.

I watch her from a short distance. Despite my best efforts at wielding a blow dryer and makeup brush in the morning, my hair has fallen flat and I can feel beads of sweat forming on my freckled nose. My mascara has probably formed dark circles under my eyes. My fingernail polish is chipped, my teeth ache, and my feet are swelling in the $12 sandals I found in the clearance section of Famous Footwear.  I could probably use a new bra, especially since I’m wearing a form fitting and garishly bright t-shirt that does absolutely nothing for my 48 year-old boobs.

IMG00226-20100625-0831It’s the kind of day that makes me feel out of my element and out of place, and the orange shirt I bought for this three-day trip to a Utah resort isn’t helping. I also bought a pair of white jeans that (I decided when I tried them on in my hotel room) make me look like an aging orderly who should be delivering J-ello in an institution rather than walking the hallways of a four-star mountain getaway.  Luckily, I’m not wearing the hospital pants — I folded them back up and opted for a loose pair of khakis.

Even then, I feel slightly creepy, like a geeky, slope-shouldered girl feels who’s donned an ill-fitting strapless taffeta dress for a prom she shouldn’t have been invited to, in the hopes that somehow she’ll blend into the environment, like a chameleon or potted plant.

The ice cream colored wardrobe was my attempt – my really wrong and clumsy attempt – to feel like the kind of summer-y, social woman who belongs at a resort. It was my way of trying to trick my hermitic, socially awkward, working-class self into feeling okay in a bustling hotel that smells of eucalyptus spa treatments and $30 dinners.

And of course, it was stupid. There are probably as many other women here who struggle with feelings of outsided-ness as those who feel like they belong. Clothes might make a person look less obviously outcast in their environment (if they’re good shoppers and have any fashion sense at all, which I don’t), but they can’t bridge the real gaps.

IMG00228-20100625-1723Earlier in the morning, I sat out on a sun-drenched balcony and watched the housekeepers cross the long expanse from the dirt parking lot to the employee entrance. It takes them about ten minutes. I’m sure they’re not paid for that time – twenty minutes a day in good weather, and probably about thirty in the winter.  Over the course of the year, that’s a lot of unpaid hours.

The housekeepers wear dark green smocks pinned with sparkling gold name tags, and most have their hair pulled back. I know that their feet probably ache when they get home, and the older ones likely have sore backs. I’m sure they can’t afford a massage with eucalyptus oil. Maybe, like my mom did after a day in retail, they go home, make dinner, clean the kitchen, give the kids a bath, and then sit in a recliner. Maybe one of their children rubs their feet in the hopes of currying favor and a later bedtime.

Maybe, like so many other working class women, they crawl into bed and dream of the day they can stop walking through dirt fields, get braces for their kids, and live in a house instead of an apartment.

My working class roots finds the dichotomy between the natural beauty of mountains and the manufactured beauty of this resort unsettling. It seems odd to me to see people in uniforms among the backdrop of pine trees. It feels strange to be in the mountains, but to have no sense of solitude or privacy – no quiet place to sit outside alone and reflect.

In the sense of “majority rules” my feelings are misplaced. People come here to bike, ski, hike, attend conferences, and take romantic gondola rides, and their needs are fulfilled. They enjoy lounging poolside, and conversing in lobbies filled with comfortable leather chairs. This is their prom, and it’s a happy occasion for them. For me, it’s a place where my heartstrings feel uneasily tugged.

I have more in common with the women in the shapeless green smocks than I do with the well-to-do woman with the bright smile, but there’s no comfort in this sense of familiarity – there’s only dread-fear and panicky memories of low-wage poverty. I flashback to cold, dark apartments, empty cupboards, broken-down cars, stony faces, and years of an exhaustion so deep I didn’t think that I’d ever fully waken.

I flashback to me: 13, washing dishes; 14, cleaning apartments; 16, working in a factory; 19, a single mother; 21, a casino cocktail waitress . . . and to all the times I held a second job, even when I was in advertising, in order to buy extras, like school clothes or dental appointments. Then there was the discovery, after a couple of years as an adult student in college, that I could actually make more as a blue-collar worker. I drove a frozen food truck. I became a massage therapist. I worked in an office filled with hostile workers. I climbed out of the worst of poverty, but was never more than one mishap or miscalculation away from disaster.

Longevity hasn’t brought me to peace with poverty, but it doesn’t scare me as it once did. I learned to do without so many things, over so many years, that even the simplest of things — like a good cup of coffee — still feel like a gift. What scares me isn’t the cold, or the hunger, or the absence of things in the poverty equation, it’s the absence of me.

What scares me is the bone-deep memory of having nothing left of myself at the end of long, fruitless days, and the sleepless nights spent fearing that if I fell asleep I wouldn’t hear the alarm clock in the morning.  What scares me is the visceral sensation of workplace antagonism: the coworkers who bullied those who ranked below them, the chronic complainers, the micro-managers, and the openly hostile or nepotistic supervisors.

Lastly, what scares me is my own lack of tolerance for such circumstances anymore, and the panic that rises in my gut whenever I think of returning to days of desperate energy and dead-end dreams.

I know that I write more for the women in the green smocks than the woman with the stylish shoes, and that there’s really no big demand for that – the shadowed underclass isn’t really a market as much as it is an undesirable demographic, and many people like stories with snap-on happy endings – but I’ll keep writing anyway. Not just because it’s what I know but because while some truths may never make it to the shelves of Barnes & Noble, it doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be told.

7 Tweets

{ 16 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Screwed Up Texan July 1, 2010 at 11:13 am

Oh we should have gotten together while we were both in Utah…I would have done it for anything…although I am sure we’d both have been two awkward women who were both out of place. But we would be out of place together and that would have made things more fun. Just think–you could have worn your nurses pants and I couldve worn my banana pants. Perfect.

I love reading your posts–I believe and know it is something most of us can relate to.
Screwed Up Texan´s last blog ..Fun and Games My ComLuv Profile

Reply   More from author

2 Neil July 1, 2010 at 11:14 am

I hope you are wrong. Everyone needs stories. These women might just get it from soap operas or movies.

Reply   More from author

3 Tara Bradford July 1, 2010 at 11:27 am

Jane, your stories are much more interesting – and authentic – than most. Please keep writing these stories, to help open people’s eyes to the realities and hardships for so many people. Rarely do their stories earn a spotlight. Well done, you!

Reply

4 Betsy July 1, 2010 at 11:42 am

your writing is amazing-looking forward to next week
Betsy´s last blog ..Father’s Day My ComLuv Profile

Reply   More from author

5 Carolyn Normandin July 1, 2010 at 11:46 am

The bleach-teeth and self-assured gait (probably in stilettos) ain’t got nothin’ on you, my friend. I’d turn in all the fashion “must-haves” in the world to be able to write like you. . .

Please keep making observations, thinking deep thoughts, and writing them down for us to identify and commiserate upon.

Reply

8 Juli Ryan July 1, 2010 at 5:11 pm

The shelves at Barnes & Noble are filled with stories about social class. Everyone likes a good Cinderella story. But also think of Wharton, Austen, Steinbeck, Fitzgerald, Cather, etc. etc. Keep writing!
Juli Ryan´s last blog ..I judge people by their book titles Im only kidding OK- sort of My ComLuv Profile

Reply   More from author

9 LBJ July 1, 2010 at 5:21 pm

Ugh. I know the feeling, and coincidentally I was at a major bookstore the other day, although not B&N. I read a lot of book blurbs and almost all of the fiction ones that looked promising were about upper middle class or rich women. Oprah’s book club used to point out some better ones, like Jeanette Walls’s book The Glass Castle, but you and Juli are both right, they all tend to have “snappy happy” or Cinderella endings.

I’ve never worn a green smock, but I often feel like you write for me. Maybe it’s because some of what you write is universal, and the rest you show us in a way that’s empathetic and powerful.

Keep writing, Jane. I’ll buy whatever you sell when you’re ready to sell it.

Reply

10 gfe--gluten free easily July 1, 2010 at 8:59 pm

Beautifully written, Jane. I could actually visualize the housekeepers in their green smocks taking the long walk and imagine the entire scene you painted. Thought-provoking piece, too.

Shirley
gfe–gluten free easily´s last blog ..Cavemen Cookies and Recipe Index My ComLuv Profile

Reply   More from author

12 Goddess Lynn July 2, 2010 at 6:05 am

I believe that the bleached teeth and perfect hair is a way of trying to rid herself of her own insecurities, her way of trying to fit it. There are those who try and keep up with the “Joneses” I suppose. I bet had you spoken to her, she’d have shared those feelings some how some way. Perhaps.
As far as you, that quality of appreciating what you have now is so obvious. You haven’t forgotten where you came from and how you got to this very moment. That is a gift. I’m so grateful that you share this gift with your readers.
Oh and those white jeans, maybe you should have envisioned that you were the character “Baby” from Dirty Dancing and danced your way down a path on those resort grounds. That’s what I think of when I see white jeans…”Nobody puts Baby in a corner” so don’t allow bobbed hair and bleach teeth make you feel that way either. Keep on keepin’ it real girlfriend.

Reply

13 MJ Tam July 3, 2010 at 11:47 am

Your writing moves me. Almost every woman can relate to the feeling of outsided-ness. BTW – I love that orange shirt! :-)

Reply   More from author

14 Ann Parker July 3, 2010 at 7:54 pm

You are so right Jane.

Reply

15 SparkleBella July 4, 2010 at 12:44 pm

Digesting, digesting, digesting this post for three days. Poignant. Insightful. Heartbreaking. So right.

I’m not brave enough to add commentary that is screaming through my head. I’m still trying to learn that’s its OK to say what I’m thinking. Which is just one of the reasons why I so admire your ability and willingness to share your very personal thoughts and experiences with all of us.

Trust me, you are also writing for the women in the stylish shoes. You rock, Jane.

Someday, over that margarita (or five), we will have interesting discussions.

Reply

16 Laura V July 6, 2010 at 8:19 am

SparkleBella is right…your writing is poignant, insightful and heartbreaking, in a way that is just right to stir us back to awareness. Thank you, Jane.

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv Enabled

Additional comments powered by BackType

Previous post: Wordless Wednesday: NYC Scenes

Next post: Detroit: Breakfast at the Holiday Inn